An Ankeny RV and trailer service shop came to us last spring with a budget question that most first-time buyers wrestle with: should he buy a used car lift automotive package off a marketplace listing or spend the extra money on a new lift from a stocked dealer? He was staring at a two-year-old lift for six thousand dollars on a listing site, versus a new unit from us at just over eleven thousand installed. This is his first-year story, told honestly, and it will save someone else five thousand dollars of the wrong kind of savings. Spoiler: the used route can work, but only under conditions this particular deal did not meet.
Every new car lift automotive package we sell ships with warranty, install, and parts pipeline included.
Why he was thinking used in the first place
He runs an Ankeny RV and trailer shop with two full-time techs and a seasonal bay. He had priced a car lift automotive four-post at three major retailers and consistently landed in the eleven to thirteen thousand range installed. The marketplace listing was a two-year-old Rotary four-post at six thousand pickup, and the seller was a body shop closing down forty miles away. He asked us to look at the listing before he pulled the trigger. That single phone call is why we exist as an independent advisor rather than just a retailer — buyers deserve a straight read on used equipment before they hand over cash.
The listing photos told most of the story. The columns looked clean, the runways were straight, and the power unit was mounted at the correct column. Two things caught our eye. The cable pulleys had visible wear grooves that indicated the lift had probably been cycled more than the seller claimed. And there was no visible ALI certification decal on the columns, which is either a missing decal or, more likely, a certification that had lapsed. A used car lift automotive purchase is worth doing only if the fundamentals check out. This one did not.
The three questions we tell every used-lift buyer to ask
First question: when was the last ALI-certified inspection and where is the paperwork. If the seller cannot produce it, assume the lift has been out of certification for years. Some Iowa jurisdictions and most insurance carriers require current certification for commercial use, and re-certifying an old lift costs eight hundred to twelve hundred dollars and sometimes uncovers repair costs that dwarf the initial savings. Second question: are the cables original. A car lift automotive four-post has four cables that carry the load, and the OEM replacement interval is around ten years. If they are original and older than seven years, budget for cables before you close.
Third question: is the power unit still under manufacturer warranty. Almost always the answer is no on a used lift, because warranty follows the original owner. That matters because power units are the most likely component to fail in years three through eight, and a new replacement is fifteen hundred to two thousand dollars installed. On his six-thousand-dollar deal, he would have been staring at a two-thousand-dollar power unit rebuild inside a year. A used car lift automotive buy is only a good deal when you can answer all three questions favorably. His deal answered none of them favorably.
What we ended up recommending instead
We steered him to a new Challenger four-post at ten thousand five hundred installed, which was our then-current commercial pricing on that model. He would get a five-year structural warranty, a two-year power unit warranty, an ALI certification decal from day one, brand-new cables with no wear, and our install crew handling anchors and torque specs. He would spend forty-five hundred dollars more than the used listing but save himself the probable repair costs on the used unit inside eighteen months. That math worked out clean, and he pulled the trigger on the new one.
To be clear, we buy and recommend used car lift automotive equipment all the time when the fundamentals check out. A three-year-old Rotary four-post from a first owner who dismantled a home garage and has the maintenance records is a fantastic buy at half retail. A no-history commercial pull from a closing shop with wear on the pulleys is not. The trick is knowing which is which, and that is what a used-vs-new decision framework is really for. It is not about avoiding used gear. It is about knowing what a used deal looks like when it is worth doing.
Install day at the Ankeny shop
Install happened on a Thursday in June. His slab was six inches of newer pour and passed our anchor evaluation without needing a shim plan. The lift was up and cycling before lunch, and we spent the afternoon walking his two techs through operator training and the ALI-mandated pre-shift inspection checklist. He signed the acceptance paperwork before the end of the day. The whole install was uneventful, which is exactly what a good car lift automotive install should be. When install day is dramatic, something got missed in the pre-install phase.
Contrast with the used purchase he considered. Even if the mechanical unit checked out, he would have paid seven hundred to eleven hundred for a professional relocation and re-anchor, on a slab that had never been evaluated for that specific lift’s anchor pattern. He would have taken possession of a lift with no warranty, no operator training package, and no local parts stock. The four-thousand-dollar upfront savings would have consumed itself in disassembly labor, freight, relocation install, and re-certification within the first three months. This is the pattern we see over and over in the used car lift automotive market.
First fluid service under the new lift
The first big job that came through was a differential fluid service on a Class C motorhome chassis. Rear differential, transfer case, and front differential all needed drain-and-fill on a 6,800-mile service interval. On the new lift the whole job took ninety minutes with one tech. Pan removal, fluid drain into a waste tote, magnetic drain plug cleanup, refill through the top fill port, torque, and lower. On jack stands the same job would have taken three hours and required a second tech for safety spot.
That single service billed at just under four hundred dollars in labor plus fluid and gasket materials. Multiply by the fluid services that pass through his shop in a season and the payback math on the new car lift automotive package writes itself. He estimated his lift would pay for itself in labor efficiency alone inside the first calendar year, ignoring any other benefit. Twelve months later he confirmed that estimate was conservative. This is the honest financial case for spending real money on a new lift rather than gambling on a used one. Time-per-service compression is where the profit actually lives.
The one thing he would change about his order
He would order the sliding bridge jacks with the lift, not two months later. He originally passed on them to save eight hundred dollars, and inside sixty days he had a differential service on a Sprinter chassis where he needed to lift one axle independently to catch a stuck driveshaft. Without the jacks he improvised with rolling floor jacks and it worked, but it took an extra forty minutes and he did not sleep well that night. Ordering the jacks with the lift would have added eight hundred to the invoice and saved him that improvisation.
Every car lift automotive four-post install should include the accessory conversation up front. Sliding jacks. Aluminum drive-on ramps. Air line kit. Alignment turntables if the shop does alignment work. We walk buyers through each accessory and explain when it earns back its cost. If the buyer skips one, we make sure the skip is intentional. This shop skipped the jacks intentionally to save money and then bought them anyway, which is the most common used-vs-new-adjacent mistake we see. Order what you need with the lift, once, and be done with it.
Where the used vs new framework lands twelve months on
Twelve months into the new lift he has zero regret. The car lift automotive investment paid back in labor efficiency inside nine months by his own count. The warranty has covered one small power unit sensor replacement at no cost. The ALI certification is current and his commercial insurance renewal went through without a hitch. He has referred two other Ankeny shops to us based on how uneventful the whole experience has been. That is exactly the outcome the framework is designed to produce.
The used lift he almost bought was picked up by another buyer six weeks after our conversation. That buyer has since reached out to us for parts because two cables snapped inside four months. That is not proof that every used lift is a bad deal — but it is proof that the specific listing he was looking at was the wrong deal, and that a used-vs-new decision framework saved him from that outcome. Call 800-674-9302 for a straight opinion on any lift you are considering. See our companion pieces on used lift inspection and RV shop lift setups.
Our Clients Include: