When a vehicle collector near Ames called us trying to decide between a used and new Challenger 39000 lift for a detached garage full of stored cars, the conversation wasn’t really about specs — it was about which choice would actually hold up over years of light, careful use. That’s the situation a lot of collectors find themselves in: you don’t need a shop-duty lift running eight cycles a day, but you do need something you trust completely with vehicles that matter to you. This is the story of how that decision played out, from the used-vs-new debate through installation and into the first scheduled service, because the lessons in between are more useful than any spec sheet.
Compare new and rebuilt Challenger two-post lifts, or call us for help sourcing a used unit near Ames with a clean inspection history.
The Used-vs-New Decision, Laid Out Honestly
Our collector’s first instinct was to save money with a used unit, and that’s a reasonable starting point — used two-post lifts show up regularly in the Midwest as shops upgrade or close, and a well-maintained used Challenger 39000 lift can run for another decade without issue. But the math isn’t just purchase price versus purchase price. A used lift comes with unknowns: hydraulic fluid history, cable wear, whether the safety locks have been serviced, and whether it was ever moved or re-anchored improperly at some point in its life. Each of those unknowns has a cost attached if it turns into a repair six months after you’ve bolted it down.
New, by contrast, means every component starts at zero hours with a manufacturer warranty behind it — real peace of mind for someone storing collector vehicles rather than daily drivers. We walked through both scenarios with him: a used unit at a lower upfront cost with a thorough inspection and likely a reservoir or seal service within the first year, versus a new Challenger 39000 lift at a higher upfront cost with nothing to inspect because nothing had failed yet. For a collector planning to keep the lift in place for many years and use it on vehicles worth protecting, he ultimately went new, and that’s the choice we’d make again in his position — though we’ve talked plenty of budget-conscious buyers into excellent used units when the inspection checked out clean.
What the Inspection Would Have Looked Like Either Way
Even choosing new, we ran him through what a used-unit inspection involves, because it’s useful knowledge for anyone shopping this model. You want to see the hydraulic power unit and reservoir for signs of leaking or corrosion — reservoirs on older two-post units are a common wear item, and replacing one isn’t a big job if you can get the right part with matching bolt pattern and neck dimensions. You want cable tension even on both sides, arm restraints that lock with no play, and safety cams that engage at the same height increment on both columns.
We also always ask about the concrete. A Challenger 39000 lift at 9,000 lb capacity needs anchors set into slab that meets minimum thickness and cure requirements, and a used lift that’s been through one or more moves is worth extra scrutiny on that front. None of this is meant to scare buyers away from used equipment — most of what we find is fixable — but going in with eyes open means no surprises land on you after the lift is already anchored in your garage.
Installation Day: What Actually Takes the Time
Once the new Challenger 39000 lift arrived, installation took the better part of a day, and most of that time wasn’t spent assembling the lift itself — it was spent getting the anchoring right. We measured slab thickness, checked for any hairline cracking near the intended footprint, and laid out the column spacing based on the widest vehicle he planned to store on it. Column spacing matters more for collectors than for shops running a mix of everyday vehicles, because if your collection leans toward wider classics or trucks, you want the spacing set for your actual fleet, not a generic average.
We also spent real time on electrical — running dedicated power to the hydraulic unit rather than sharing a circuit with garage lighting or a compressor, which avoids nuisance trips and voltage sag that can affect lift speed over time. By the end of the day the lift was level, anchored, and cycling smoothly through full range with the safety locks engaging cleanly at every increment we tested.
The First Few Months: Learning the Lift’s Habits
Every lift has small habits you only learn by using it. Our customer noticed the arms swung slightly stiffer on one side for the first several weeks — completely normal as bushings and pivot points wear in, but worth mentioning because a new owner unfamiliar with that can mistake normal break-in for a defect. We told him to keep an eye on it and grease the pivot points on the schedule in the owner’s manual rather than waiting for a problem to show up.
He also learned quickly that a Challenger 39000 lift used for careful, occasional storage-and-retrieval work behaves differently than one cycling constantly in a repair bay. Lower cycle counts mean less wear, but it also means it’s easy to forget the lift needs any maintenance at all when months go by without a service call. We suggested he put a reminder on the calendar rather than relying on memory, since collector-use lifts are exactly the kind that get neglected simply because they’re not being used every day.
The First Scheduled Service: What We Checked
Around the one-year mark, we came back out for the first scheduled service. This is standard for any two-post lift regardless of use pattern — even light collector use benefits from an annual look at cable tension, hydraulic fluid condition, and anchor bolt torque. On his unit we found nothing alarming: cable tension was even, no fluid weeping from the cylinder seals, and the safety cams still engaged cleanly at matching heights on both columns.
We did retorque a couple of anchor bolts that had settled slightly, which is normal in the first year after a new install as the concrete and anchor system settle under repeated load cycles. We also topped off hydraulic fluid slightly and walked him through what to watch for between now and the next service — mainly listening for new noises during operation and checking that the arm restraints still engage with zero play. That’s really the whole maintenance story for a well-installed Challenger 39000 lift in light-duty collector use: not much goes wrong if the install was done right and someone’s paying occasional attention.
What We’d Tell Any Collector Making This Same Call
Looking back on this first year, the biggest lesson wasn’t about the lift itself — it was about matching the decision to the actual use case. A collector storing and rotating vehicles a few times a month doesn’t need the same lift a five-bay shop needs, but that doesn’t mean corners can be cut on installation quality or the fundamentals of arm restraints, safety-cam engagement, and anchoring. Those basics matter identically whether the lift sees ten cycles a year or ten a day, because the vehicles at risk if something fails are just as valuable either way — arguably more so for a collector.
If you’re weighing used versus new for your own garage, our advice mirrors what we told him: run the real numbers on likely near-term repair costs for a used unit, be honest about how much you value warranty coverage, and never skip the concrete and anchoring diligence regardless of which way you go. For more on this decision process, see our articles on buying a used two-post lift and what a proper two-post installation should include, and if you’re storing collector vehicles specifically, our piece on lifts for long-term vehicle storage is worth a read too.
Our Clients Include: